Benalla Sustainable Future Group
  • Home
  • ABOUT
    • ABOUT BSFG
    • ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCACY
    • FUNDING
  • GROUPS
    • Building >
      • Building Overview
      • BSFG's Guide to Sustainable Housing
      • 9 steps to sustainable housing
    • Education
    • Energy >
      • Energy Overview
      • Renewable Energy Benalla
    • Food >
      • Food Overview
      • Benalla Food Co-operative
      • Benalla Local Food Network
      • Permaculture and Sustainable Gardening
    • Lobbying/Media
    • Localisation >
      • Benalla Local Food Network
    • Waste >
      • Plastic >
        • Plastic Overview
        • Plastic Wise Benalla
        • Plastic Wise News
    • TRANSPORT >
      • Cycling >
        • Bicycle Action Group
        • Cycling in Benalla
      • Electric Vehicles >
        • Electric Vehicles - Overview
        • 'The Driven' - News
        • 'The Driven' - Podcasts
  • Food Co-op
  • NEWS
    • News
    • Newsletter
    • Hot Topics
    • Light Ideas
  • JOIN
    • Join BSFG
    • Membership Form
  • Calendar
  • Links
    • BSFG Likes...
    • Catch Up videos
    • Ecoportal
    • North East Region Sustainability Alliance (NERSA)
    • Benalla Permaculture
    • Bendigo Sustainability Group
    • Totally Renewable Yackandandah
  • Contact

Logging in the Strathbogie Forest - Peter Holmes

6/10/2016

7 Comments

 
Some of you may already be aware from the news reports in the Benalla Ensign and Country News (21st September), of the situation in the Strathbogie State Forest in the Lima East area, regarding plans by Vicforests to clearfell log a 40 hectare coupe along Parlours Creek.

Members of the Strathbogie Sustainable Forests group have been in discussions with Victorian State government departments and politicians on numerous occasions, firstly successfully lobbying to have the planned burning regime altered to a “need to protect built asset” basis, rather than a blanket 5% per year burn-off, and more recently, had commenced discussions about selective logging, as opposed to clear-fell logging.

The Strathbogie Forest in this area is a mixed species forest of high value for both flora and fauna. There are many large old trees with hollows that support Powerful Owls and Sugar Gliders, and the forest is also home to a good population of Koalas.
​
VicForests is a commercial enterprise of the Victorian government, but it is very heavily subsidised by taxpayer funds. Returns from clear-felling are estimated to be no more than around $40 per hectare in this forest – a disgraceful return given the environmental destruction that is caused by this method of logging. A previous coupe in a nearby location has not recovered in 10 years, despite 3 attempts by VicForests to re-habilitate the coupe. The coupe is generally left as a single species (eucalypt) area, and earmarked for logging again many years later, usually for wood chips. All of this could be much better achieved through growing timber plantations in appropriate locations.
 
If you are interested in learning more about this situation, or wish to become involved in trying to stop the destruction of the Strathbogie Forest, you can follow the progress by Googling the website – “ Our Strathbogie Forest”  (www.strathbogiesustainableforests.wordpress.com)
 
Peter Holmes

By coincidence there was an opinion article in The Age on Wednesday 5th Oct., titled “Logging makes no sense” which really backs up the point made by Peter about the very poor economic return from logging. The article emphasises that unlogged native forest are worth more than logged ones.

John Lloyd

 
7 Comments
Mark Blackwell
12/10/2016 02:14:29 pm

I presume that the residents of Benalla will be happy that the McNulteys mill will shut. Hardwood is accessed from various forest for various mills. Shut the mills down but don't complain when the employment disappears in Benalla.

Reply
Peter Holmes
12/10/2016 09:02:33 pm

The respondent to my article about logging in the Strathbogie State Forest has totally ignored the fact that Vicforests sells off the timber for woodchips. SSF is not opposed to sustainable harvesting by selective logging, which will still allow the forest to recover and not destroy precious habitat. McNultys can still access hardwood timber in that fashion, or better still from hardwood plantations.

Reply
Mark Blackwell
21/12/2016 03:45:49 pm

That is plain not truthful. Not one hour ago I returned from the forest. I would be careful about the allegations you are making

Reply
Glenn Martin
8/1/2017 10:47:02 am

If you wish to save the world, don`t worry about some minuscule one off logging cope in Victoria

Stop advances in medical science now and increase funding for birth control or were all doomed.

Reply
Peter Maddock
10/3/2017 05:14:55 pm

Yes Glen. Population is the elephant in the room when it comes to environmental problems. And the population of Victoria is expected to hit 10 million people by the 2050s and Melbourne's population will double by 2031, new figures indicate, http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-07-15/melbourne-double-in-size-as-victorias-population-10million/7632700. Unfortunately our economy is driven by growth which relies on population growth. This can only put more pressure on what remains of our natural environment.

Reply
Peter Maddock
10/3/2017 05:39:05 pm

From Population Matters, "Population growth is stifling our green and pleasant land" at https://www.populationmatters.org/chris-packham-speaks-impact-population/?utm_content=buffer01a70&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer

Reply
yvonne szwedyc
11/2/2017 07:25:22 pm

I stopped for a tiger quoll to cross the road at Lima East. Tried everyway I knew to get people interested. Donated money to have dogs trained to sniff out scat. All to no avail.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    BSFG News

    Regular updates on sustainability issues of concern to BSFG members in Benalla and North East Victoria and on key events in the BSFG calendar.

    RSS Feed

    Current Newsletter

    Categories

    All
    '2040'
    'A Climate Of Change'
    Action On Climate Change
    A Day In The Gardens
    Advocacy
    Albatross
    Annual General Meeting
    Barjarg-flat
    Battery-powered-homes
    Benalla-20-year-plan
    Benalla Business Network
    BenallaEnergy4Business
    Benalla Food Cooperative
    Benalla Grow Your Own
    Benalla Health
    Benalla Local Food Network
    'Benalla Permaculture'
    Benalla Rural City
    Benalla's Baseline Emissions
    Benalla's Renewable Energy Future Forum
    Benalla's Renewable Energy Transition Plan
    Benalla Toyota
    Bertram Lobert
    Beyond Zero Emissions
    Bicycle Action Group
    Big Weather
    Biodiversity
    BPACC
    BSFG Committee
    BSFG General Meeting
    BSFG Newsletter
    BSFG President
    BSFG Stalls
    Building
    Carole Hammond
    Catherine Macmillan
    Cathy McGowan MP
    Central Benalla Community Garden
    Charles Massy
    Chris Jordan
    Christine Holmes
    Church Street Surgery
    Citizen Science
    Climate Change
    Climate Change And Refugees
    'Climate Change Conversations' In Benalla/
    Climate Change Science
    Climate Council
    Climate Emergency
    Committee Of Management
    Community Energy
    Community Energy Forum 2018
    Community Energy Model
    Community Energy Retailer
    Community Forum
    Community Gardens
    Community Markets
    COVID-19
    Craig Reucassel
    DC Power
    Decarbonisation
    Developing A Vision For Benalla/
    DEWLP
    D&R Henderson
    Dr Leanne Webb
    Dr Lynette Bettio
    Dr Tilman Ruff
    'Ecoportal'
    Elections
    Electric Vehicles
    Energy Audit
    Environmental Justice Australia
    Environmentally Sustainable Business Award
    Ethical Energy Retailers
    Extreme Storms And Blackout In SA
    Facing The Heat Workshop In Wodonga
    Federal Budget
    Fight For Planet A
    Film Screening
    Fiona Roberts
    Food Cooperative
    Food Security
    Friends Of The Earth
    FRV Services
    Gecko Clan
    General Meeting
    Get Up Petition To Govt /
    Goulburn Broken Catchment
    Goulburn Valley Environment Group
    Greater Glider
    Green Electricity Guide /
    Greta Thunberg
    Grow Free Carts
    Hemp Building Workshops
    Hot Topics
    Howard Bartlett
    Hugh McKay
    Hume Region Climate Change Adaptation Plan
    Hume Region Renewable Energy Roadmap
    Ian Herbert
    Images Of 2015 AGM
    Indigo Power
    John Lloyd
    Jordan Osmand
    Kathryn McQualter
    "Kiss The Ground"
    Leigh Ewbank
    Lightsource BP Urbis
    'Little Talks To Big' Video
    Lobbying And Media
    Local Case Studies
    Local Food Network
    Localisation
    Media Release
    Membership Fees
    Mondo Energy
    Naomi Klein Film
    Neil Garrett
    NE Local Food Strategy 2018-2022
    'NERSA'
    Newsletter
    Nobel Peace Ride In Benalla
    North East Artisans
    Open Food Network
    'Our Strathbogie Forest'
    Paris Climate Agreement
    Paris Climate Talks
    'People's Climate March'
    Permaculture
    Permaculture Course /
    Peter Holmes
    Peter Maddock
    Petitions
    Plastic Bag Action Group
    Plastic Free July
    'Plastic Wars'
    Plastic Wise
    Plastic Wise Benalla
    Platypus Conservancy
    Point Of No Return
    Presentation To Council
    Prof Samantha Hepburn
    Prof Tim Reeves
    Public Consultation Trifecta
    Raimond Gaita And Katerina Gaita
    Rakali Talks
    Recommended Reading
    Recycled Art
    Recycled String Band
    Regenerative Agriculture
    'Regional Waste Plan'
    Renewable Energy Benalla
    Renewable Energy For Benalla
    Renwable Energy Benalla
    Resilience Workshop
    Restrictions On Environment Charities /
    Retrofitting
    Richard Flanagan
    Ross Gittins
    School Strike For Climate Change
    'SCRAP' - Swanpool's Creative Recycled Art Prize
    Serenity Hill
    Shannon Loughnane
    Shirley Saywell
    Short Supply Chains
    Solar Power
    Solar Skillion Sleep Out
    'Speed Date A Sustainability Expert'
    Stop Adani
    Strathbogie Forest
    Strathbogie Sustainable Forest Group
    Strathbogie Sustainable Forests Group
    Strathbogie Voices
    Sun Real
    Sustainability
    Sustainability Vic.
    Sustainability Victoria
    Sustainable Gardens And Farms Group
    Sustainable House Day
    Sustainable Housing Forums 2016
    Swanpool Cinema
    Swanpool Environmental Film Festival
    Talking Energy
    Tasmanian Wilderness Fires
    The Source
    'The Zillion Year Town'
    'This Changes Everything'
    Tim Bowtel
    Tim Bowtell
    Truth To Power
    Turtles
    Urban Planning
    Val Dunin
    Victoria's Broken Nature Laws
    Victoria's Renewable Energy Target /
    Walk For Climate Action
    Warwick Bone
    Waste And Resource Recovery Implementation Plan/
    Waste Matters
    Wendy Baker
    Wicking Beds
    Window To Window
    Winton Solar Farm
    Winton Wetlands
    'Wipe Out Electricity & Gas Bills'
    World Pulse Day
    World Wetlands Day
    Xiuhtezcatl Martinez
    Yackandandah Festival Of Dangerous Ideas

    Archives

    February 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015

    RSS Feed

Mailing List
Membership Form
News Blog
Newsletter
Site Map
Light Ideas
Action Groups:
Benalla Food Cooperative
Benalla Local Food Network
Plastic Wise Benalla
​Renewable Energy Benalla

Donate to Support BSFG
Photo used under Creative Commons from davebloggs007